Are Asphalt Shingles Still a Good Choice for Show Low Homes?

For decades, asphalt shingles have been a go-to roofing material for homeowners across the U.S., and Show Low is no exception. They are widely used, relatively affordable, and available in a range of colors and styles. With changing weather patterns and rising interest in alternatives like metal and tile, many homeowners wonder whether asphalt shingles remain the right choice for a home in Show Low, Arizona. Metal roofing has gained attention for durability, wind resistance, and snow performance, which makes the decision more nuanced.

This article examines how shingles perform in Show Low’s climate, compares them to other materials, and summarizes common considerations from local professionals. If planning to contact a shingle roofing company or considering options, this guide provides a solid foundation.

What makes Show Low’s climate unique?

Before choosing a roofing material, it helps to understand what a roof will face. Show Low sits at over 6,000 feet in elevation and experiences a mix of weather not typical in many parts of Arizona. Homeowners face:

● Snow and ice in winter, which may cause expansion, contraction, and freeze-thaw cycles.
● Heavy UV exposure in summer, especially on south-facing slopes.
● Monsoon rains and windstorms, which test the integrity of shingles, panels, and flashing.
● Pine needles and debris in forested areas, which may trap moisture and clog valleys.

This combination of sun, snow, and storm makes material choice less straightforward than in lower-elevation desert cities. Metal roofing’s ability to shed snow, resist wind uplift, and reflect sunlight often factors into the decision alongside shingles.

The pros of asphalt shingles in Show Low

Despite the challenges, asphalt shingles are still widely installed by many crews, including any shingle roofing contractor servicing the region. Reasons include:

Affordability

Asphalt shingles remain among the most cost-effective materials. For budget-conscious projects, they allow quality installation with a lower upfront expense than metal or tile.

Ease of repair

Shingle damage, such as cracking or lifting, is relatively easy and inexpensive to address. Local roofers can swap out individual shingles with minimal disruption, whereas metal systems may require panel-specific techniques.

Style variety

Architectural (dimensional) shingles are available in styles that mimic wood or slate, providing an upgraded appearance without specialty materials.

Readily available

Most shingle roofing company suppliers keep asphalt shingles in stock, which supports quicker scheduling during peak seasons.

The cons of asphalt shingles in Show Low

Certain drawbacks matter in a high-altitude, four-season environment, especially when compared with metal.

Shorter lifespan than metal or tile

High-quality architectural shingles may last 20–30 years, which is typically shorter than metal, often expected to last several decades with proper maintenance. Intense UV and snow load may further affect performance if ventilation and flashing are not detailed correctly.

More prone to wind damage

Shingles may lift or tear in high winds, which are common during the monsoon season. Metal systems often feature interlocking seams and concealed fasteners that help resist uplift when specified correctly.

Heat absorption

Dark shingles tend to absorb heat. In summer, attic temperatures may rise unless ventilation is optimized. Highly reflective metal finishes can mitigate heat gain in comparable conditions.

How asphalt shingles compare to metal and tile

Asphalt shingles are:
● Affordable and straightforward to install
● Available in many styles and colors
● Expected to last 20–30 years with maintenance

Compared to:
● Metal roofing: Higher upfront cost, often a longer service life, strong performance in snow and wind, and energy-reflective finishes
● Tile roofing: Very durable and heat-tolerant, but heavier and typically more expensive, with structural considerations

Shingles are budget-friendly, while metal and tile often deliver longer life and stronger performance in Show Low’s extremes. A trusted shingle roofing contractor can help evaluate insulation, ventilation, and flashing details for either material.

So, is it still a good choice?

For many homeowners in Show Low, asphalt shingles remain a practical option when installed and maintained by an experienced crew. Selecting high-quality architectural shingles, ensuring proper ventilation and flashing, and scheduling inspections after storms or winter seasons are essential. For those planning to stay long term or seeking reduced maintenance, standing seam metal may be worth exploring for snow shedding, wind resistance, and finish longevity.

Conclusion

Asphalt shingles continue to suit many Show Low homes due to affordability, familiar installation, and style options. They are not always the best long-term fit, particularly for properties prioritizing durability and weather resilience. A knowledgeable shingle roofing company or shingle roofing contractor can compare shingle and metal specifications, then recommend an installation that aligns with Show Low’s climate and the home’s structure.